Friday, October 27, 2006

Refereeing tips

If the first thought that come to mind was football, then this post will not be helpful. It provides advice to academic economists on how to write critiques of other economists' research.

From Tyler Cowen of Marginal Revolution:

Here are my tips:

1. Assume that no referee reports are truly anonymous. It is fine to be critical but always be polite.

2. Unless it is immediate junk, read the paper once and return to it a week later with deeper thoughts and a fresh mind.

3. Your report should not assume that the editor has a working knowledge of the paper in his mind.

4. Respond within a month. First it is considerate to the author. Second, the less "fresh" the task is, the more painful it will be.

5. A properly critical and useful "accept" report is harder to write. Don't look for excuses to quickly reject a potentially good paper.

6. The editor might have chosen you as referee for a reason. You need not go along with the editor's grand plan or desired outcome, but be aware it may exist.

7. Don't check the references to see if you are cited.

Here is a short article full of good advice. Here is the longer piece (which I have not read) on how to publish in top journals. Thanks to Elaine Hawley for the pointer.

16 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi Economist,

Thanks very much for your interesting blog. It's always nice to see how people on the other side of the globe live, how they share the same joys and sorrows, what they do in their free time, etc.

I actually have a question about your blog. Would you mind helping us with a linguistic research project? We're compiling data from various Singaporean weblogs. All it requires is checking a few boxes. If you want to take part and/or have more questions, drop me a note ( hack2301@uni-trier.de RE: Question ) so that I can then send you the 'official' project eMail. We'd really appreciate your help.

Thanks very much in advance!
Best regards,
- Fran

9:42 PM  
Anonymous オテモヤン said...

オナニー
逆援助
SEX
フェラチオ
ソープ
逆援助
出張ホスト
手コキ
おっぱい
フェラチオ
中出し
セックス
デリヘル
包茎
逆援
性欲

1:48 AM  
Blogger 愛鋒頭 said...

成人圖庫,口交技巧,成人18,自慰方法,Fleshlight,情色自拍貼圖,成人情色貼圖,少婦自拍,一夜情聊天,本土av,色情av,av圖片,色情聊天,成人情色網,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,080視訊聊天室icandy,情色少女貼圖,免費視 訊聊天網,av女優18,免費線上視訊fm358,avdvd免費AV女優,女優王國,做愛,無碼影片,情色交友

2:04 PM  
Blogger 請不要走 said...

失意人前,勿談得意事;得意人前,勿談失意事。..................................................

12:23 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

thx u very much, i learn a lot

10:09 AM  
Blogger Cryster said...

Hi economist,

I stumbled upon your blog today while doing a research on my economic essay. Thank you so much for this blogged, it provided me with lots of examples I can use in my essay =].
Thank you!

Best regards,
Cryster, Singapore.

6:08 PM  
Anonymous romanya vizesi said...

thank you very much for information

4:56 PM  
Blogger SingaporeMemoryProject said...

Dear Sir/Madam,

On behalf of the National Library Board (NLB), we would like to invite you to pledge your blog to the Singapore Memory Project as part of efforts to collect memories that are already manifested in existing online channels.

The Singapore Memory Project (SMP) is a national initiative to collect, preserve and provide access to Singapore’s knowledge materials. Spearheaded by NLB, the SMP aims to build a national collection of content in diverse formats (including print, audio and video), to preserve them in digital form, and make them available for discovery and research.

By pledging your blog to SMP, you are affirming that every memory matters. Whether your posts are an account of your daily life, or an expression of your thoughts, the SMP hopes to find a home for your memories so that it can help build towards an understanding of Singapore. You will also receive a badge that you can display on your blog in recognition of your contributions.

Contributors to this blog pledging initiative will be listed on Singapore Memory portal’s blog pledging webpage. All blogs pledged to SMP will archived using NLB’s web harvesting software, in addition to images of each blog’s landing page.

If you are keen to pledge your blog to SMP, simply fill up our response form at this following URL: http://singaporememory.simulation.com.sg/Public/Pledge.

You may find out more about this initiative at http://www.iremember.sg/?page_id=2822.

We are looking forward to your contribution.

Simulation Software & Technology (S2T) Pte Ltd
583 Orchard Road #14-02 Forum The Shopping Mall S(238884), Singapore
|w: www.simulation.com.sg

3:22 PM  
Blogger Standard Solutions said...

Great tips ...Keep posting such quite excellent info .Thank you for sharing.
SEO Lahore

4:53 PM  
Blogger Nellie Pease said...

Nice And Informative Website. Please Keep Continue Such Kind Of Effort. I Shared Your Post With My Friends Also. Priya Mumbai Escort Service. We Deal In High Class Mumbai Models And Beautiful Mumbai Call Girls. We Are Available To Serve You 24 X 7. Contact Us For Booking Ph- 09987215552
Website - http://www.escortagencyinmumbai.com
mumbai escort service
Mumbai escorts
escort service in Mumbai
mumbai call girls
Andheri escorts
Bandra escorts

1:37 AM  
Blogger Ritu Sharma said...

Your Website Is Nice And Informative. Please Keep Continue Such Kind Of Good Effort. My Name Is Ritu Sharma. I Run My Own Independent Mumbai Escorts Service. I Provide You VIP And Independent Escort Service In Low Cost. You Can Avail My Mumbai Escort Service At Your Own Place Or In Hotel. I Am Available To Serve You 24 X 7. If You Want To Test Me, Visit- www.escortservicemumbai.net Please Call Me- +91 9OO4OO9481
Independent Mumbai Escorts Service
mumbai escorts
mumbai escort service
escort service in mumbai
independent mumbai escorts
Independent escorts service
independent escorts

9:10 AM  
Blogger Aanaya said...

Bangalore Escorts high-class Model, Air-Hostess We offer Top class female Bangalore escorts North Indian, Punjabi, Gujarati model escorts in Bangalore Girlfriend Experience with North/South Indian Model Escort.These girls carry special essence with the natural aroma, which can simply amplify energy to men thoughts and can turn them on to get in a mood. These model escorts are multi-talented, they can make your time more lively by playing music, she can take a step with you and dances with you to live the moment completely.
Bangalore Escort
Bangalore Escort Service
Bangalore Escort Service Agency
Escort Service in Bangalore
call girl service in Bangalore
Call girl in Bangalore
Adult Service in Bangalore

10:23 PM  
Blogger Aanaya said...

Siliguri Escort Service
Siliguri Escort
Escort Service in Siliguri
Siliguri Escort Service Agency
Escort Siliguri
Call girl Service in Service
Our only wish is that you get all kinds of goodness from us. Our service is available in-call and out call Hotel service. And all the girls we have to keep you happy and most decent high profile escort Service in Siliguri with excellent quality to vip decent independent escort girls ready for full satisfy all your requirements and full cooperative service giving you. Siliguri Escort Service,Call girl Service in Siliguri.

10:24 PM  
Blogger Aanaya said...

Vadodara Escort
Vadodara Escort Service
Escort Service in Vadodara
Vadodara Escort Ajency
Call girl Service in Vadodara
Call Girl Vadodara
Beauty Queen provides you high profile independent girl in Vadodara, escorts service in Vadodara, Vadodara escorts. If you are looking for the ultimate encounter in Vadodara then I am your sophisticated young Vadodara escorts service provides upscale companionship for making your night becomes true. Hot Collection Provide By Russian Escorts Indian Models Call Girls In Vadodara Enjoy Escorts Service, available in Vadodara 24/7*.

10:25 PM  
Blogger Aanaya said...

Surat Escort Service
Surat Escort
Surat Escort Service Ajency
Escort Service in Surat
Call Girl service in Surat
call gilr Surat
surat escort service in surat 100% Safe & Secure High-Class Services Affordable Rate 100% Satisfaction, Unlimited Enjoyment. Any Time for Model/Teens Escort in Surat High-class luxury and premium escorts agency.high-class luxury and premium escorts agency We Provide Well Educated, Royal Class Female, High-class Escorts agency offering a top high-class escorts service in Surat, call girl service in Surat.

10:25 PM  
Blogger Aanaya said...

Abu Dhabi Escort Service
Abu Dhabi Escort
Abu Dhabi Escort Service Ajency
Abu Dhabi Call girl Service
Escort Service in Abu Dhabi
call girl Abu Dhabi
Abu Dhabi Escoert Service , The Perfection of Pleasure Moulded by Pretty Model Abu dhabie Escort Service, call girl Abu Dhabi. Biggest escort directory of independent escorts, escort agencies and strip clubs in Abu Dhabi, UAE. You find here the best female and male escorts providing massage and escort services.Abu Dhabi Call girl service.

10:26 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home